Will somebody please tell me?

partha_mech02 - Development Consultants, India
(not verified)
Posted in: , on 29. May. 2006 - 14:35

Dear Sir,

I am new in industry line. I want to know how to design bag filters. Basically, I want to know, how to calculate the capacity of the bagfilters for venting from various equipments like beltconveyor, truck unloaders, vibro feeders, hoppers, air slides etc..? then how to calculate the fan capacity of the bag filters. please help me.

I am a fresher in design line. I am appointed as a design engineer in cement division.

Regards,

Partha Pratim Sarkar

Added by Moderator:

bag_filter_system

Bag filter system

Re: Will Somebody Please Tell Me?

Posted on 30. May. 2006 - 08:24

Partha,

It depends on what you mean by design. As I understand it you have a plant with a number of dust generating points.

1 - you need hoods at the dust generation points to capture the dust.

2 - you need ducting to collect the dust and run it to the Baghouse.

3 - You need a baghouse and a dust extraction fan. Remember to keep the rain out of the fan discharge duct, and you may need some noise control.

4 - You need sufficient bags to trap the dust and drop it in the hopper.

5 - You need a dust disposal method to empty the hopper without generating large clouds of dust.

My approach would be the other way around.

1 - find out how much air you need by considering each dust generation point. If you have to start from nothing a Dust Control Handbook or Industrial Ventilation Manual will give a basic outline. But when it comes to "how little air can you get away with" you need some experienced advice.

2 - design of dust hoods needs experience. If the face velocity is too high - say 15 m/s - you will suck product off your machines instead of dust. These heavier particulates will cause problems in the ducts and at the filter bags.

3 - dust ducting is usually calculated on about 20 m/s. Anything less will not scour the ducts clean and create problems. But it depends to some extent on the size and density of the dust particles.

4 - the fan will have to deal with clean bags and dirty bags. As the bags get dirty the suction pressure drop increases and the air flow at the fan drops. This reduces the duct velocities as well and may cause problems.

5 - once you have the total air flow you can talk to your Baghouse Vendor about the rest. The key is the air-to-cloth ratio, or keeping the velocity low through the cloth. It could vary between 65m/hr/m2 to 180:1. If this is too high you will have problems with blinding up the bags, drastically reduced bag life, and reduced air flow. There are a number of variables to discuss - such as type of cloth, fire rating, surface finish and so on.

It took me several years to learn all that - and with the help of professional Dust Engineers. So keep it simple for a start - it will save a lot of money for your Company.

partha_mech02 - Development Consultants, India
(not verified)

Thank You Very Much

Posted on 30. May. 2006 - 08:48

thank you very much sirs....it will help me lot...again i have lot of questions.

there are some thumb rules for calculating air requirement. According to that i have to fix the capacity of the bag filters. will you please tell me the thumb rules?

again how can i fix the number of bags, compressed air requirement for the pulse jet bag filters...etc..

i am waiting for your kind replies.

agai i am very much thankfull to you all sir.

regards,

Partha

Re: Will Somebody Please Tell Me?

Posted on 31. May. 2006 - 02:21

For a Design Engineer in a Cement Division you may be asking the wrong questions, so I hesitate to give you answers.

I have just read the proceedings from a 2-day Seminar on Dust & Fume Control and I don't find any rules of thumb there. The hardest problem in dust control is to accurately determine the amount of air needed in any specific application. Once that is established the rest is easy.

So to take a blind guess and give some rules of thumb would not help anyone.

Talk to a couple of dust control Vendors, such as DCE. If you need more specific answers, or an independent check hire a Dust Control Engineer.

This business is a trap for young players. It can cost your firm a lot of money if you commit spending to a few rules of thumb.

partha_mech02 - Development Consultants, India
(not verified)

Sorry Sir

Posted on 31. May. 2006 - 10:56

here is the catch.....how can i calculate the exact air requirement from every extraction point...i have tried lot to find but all are in vain..no one can tell me the exact way to calculate the air requirement.

i am just a trainee engineer...so my questions are silly...please do not mind....i want to learn.

please help me.

regards,

Partha Pratim Sarkar

Re: Will Somebody Please Tell Me?

Posted on 31. May. 2006 - 07:10

Dear Partha,

The air requirement of a dedusting system for cement depends on the application.

Do you really want to dedust a location or do you just want to maintain a slight under pressure to prevent air born dust outside that location.

Depending on the dust load, the minimum air volume, pipe diameter, filter area and pressure drop of the fan is chosen or calculated.

This is a pneumatic conveying calculation.

If installation leakages are determining the air volume , that air volume is then the basis for the definitive design.

The intake of the dedusting should consist of a hood, where the air velocity is starting at approx. 0.8 m/sec (only pick up the dust) increasing to the duct velocity of approx. 10 m/sec (CEMENT)

Multiple intake points require extensive pressure drop calculations, where pipe diameters and pipe lengths determine the division of air through the respective parallel and combined lines.

False air inlets (controllable) can help or can be used to regulate afterwards.

Filter area (cement) is chosen as 2 times the required air extraction.

The fan capacity is chosen as 2 times the filter area.

The pressure drop over the filter at required air extraction volume is estimated at 300 mmWC

Quite a complicated puzzle.

success.

Teus

Designing Bag Filters

Posted on 1. Jun. 2006 - 12:29

If you don't know how to do this, get someone to do it for you. It is very easy to get it wrong if you don't have experience.

Show your problem to three bag filter manufacturers and ask for quotes which include the design of the duct system and guarantees of performance.

Michael Reid.

Learning Dust Control

Posted on 1. Jun. 2006 - 03:32

Partha,

You are a trainee engineer. If you want to learn I would recommend the following:

1 - At University all your assignments are packaged, relevant data attached and the answer calculable. Real engineering is not like that.

2 - As engineers we are often asked to make decisions without having all the facts - a calculated guess if you like.

3 - It is recommended that you read some basic texts on the subject

--- Industrial Ventilation - a manual of recommended practice - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists.

--- Dust Control Handbook - Vinit Mody & Raj Jakhete - Pollution Technology Review No 161.

4 - You don't live in a vacuum. At the Cement Division there are many full-scale examples of successful, and unsuccessful, dust control components. Study their performance on site, talk to the Operators, get out the drawings - you can learn a lot this way.

5 - Look at the size of the exhaust duct, the details of the hood, the open air faces, and the side gaps. Estimate the area and compare with the 0.8 m/s rule of thumb. This is learning in the real world.

6 - Don't be afraid to talk to the Vendors even if you don't have a contract on the table. They know that down the tract you are a potential customer.

Re: Will Somebody Please Tell Me?

Posted on 4. Dec. 2014 - 10:18

Dear Dear isbalanli,


1) Could you please clarify why you have not considered your calculations based on Maximum capacity of baghouse 53000 m3/hr.

I mean : Design load = 53000/60 (m3/min ) / 529 (m3) = 1.66 m/min

You are correct, I mistook the number of bags for the filter area.


2) What is the difference between max. capacity 53000 m3/hr (provided by baghouse manufacturer) and design load of 25000 m3/hr (considered by dust collection system designer)? and where this 25000 m3/hr comes from?!

It is best to ask this question to the baghouse manufacturer and the dust collection system designer.

Probably:

-53000 m3/hr is the filter fan volume at no pressure drop

-25000 m3/hr at the designed operating filter pressure drop.


Coming back to our bag filter discussion, how much can I load my baghouse of a maximum capacity of 53000 m3/hr??!! If I follow your rule of thumb {{Fan volume in m3/min = 2 * filter area(m2)}} then I can load 2*529 m2 = 1058 m3/min = 63480 m3/hr which is 10480 m3/hr more than rated max. baghouse capacity. Am I allowed to to this?! What happens If I overload my baghouse by choosing stronger blowers. Please remember that my baghouse catalog says that it can operate up to 4 inWG and I am currently reading 1.5 inWG (between clean and dirty area).

According to the rule of thumb, the allowable air volume would be:

Bag load * Area = 0.5 m/min * 529 * 60 = 15870 m3/hr

Obviously, the bag house designer calculates a filter load of 25000/60/529 = 0.788 m/min.

The resulting filter pressure drop is related to the dust load and the rate of contamination.

Have a nice day

Teus

Re: Will Somebody Please Tell Me?

Posted on 12. Dec. 2015 - 10:26

Begin studying Industrial Ventilation book, them you can understand dust collecting and later you can study bag filter design.

Bag Filters Made Of Modern Filtration Materials

Posted on 6. Mar. 2016 - 08:56

Over recent years, many enterprises have paid special attention to the reduction of environmental load on the environment. Pollution of the environment with various solid substances causing habitat degradation and affecting human health is one of the most acute problems facing Russia today. For this reason, requirements for dust concentrations at the outlet of dust and gas collecting systems become more stringent.

Electrostatic precipitators and bag filters are the most common type of dust and gas collecting equipment employed by Russian enterprises.

However, in some cases, it is impractical from an economic standpoint to replace electrostatic precipitators with similar electrostatic cleaning devices especially when it comes to complete replacement of worn-out equipment or new construction. One of the most economically viable trends in the design and manufacture of dust and gas collecting equipment is a significant increase in the use of bag filters. Bag filter characteristics are very close to those of electrostatic precipitators. However, bag filters surpass ESP in terms of residual dust content.

Bag filters are used more often due to the fact that new filtering materials with high thermal and chemical resistance appear in the market. .

The use of pleated filtration materials increases filtering area several-fold, while overall dimensions remain unchanged. As a result, they involve the lowest possible RUB/ filtration area square meter of ratio. This all makes it possible for our customers to save significantly on retrofitting costs and new projects.

Strommashina Samara plant manufactures and supplies jet-pulse and reverse air filters of different sizes and different efficiency. Residual dust concentration at the outlet will not exceed 10mg/cubic meter. Thus, compliance with applicable emission limit values is achieved.

Please click on the following link for more details about our dust and gas collecting equipment

Design Of Dust Collectors

Posted on 26. Apr. 2016 - 09:34

Dear Friends,

You may like to refer to my article "DESIGN GUIDE FOR DUST COLLECTORS" published by Chemical Engineering magazine as as a mean "feature" article. This is a complete design guide covering all aspects of dust collector design, specifications, and selection. Let me know if you would like to get a copy.

Regards,

Amrit Agarwal

Pneumatic Conveying Consulting

Email: polypcc@aol.com