Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 10:32

Shane:

I first assume you are asking about a gravity counterweight.

1. elastic stretch for all dyamic start and stop and steady-state cases, dynamics include "what if" scenarios

2. thermal stretch for the design range

3. belt sag allowance during dynamic states

4. belt maintenance allowance for splice and repair - we recommend two full splice repairs

5. end clearances for alarm and avoidance of impact against structures

Fixed takeup travel is a little more complex to give a short response.

There are other considerations when evaluating extensive TUP travel that may need to be controlled such as the use of capstans. Capstans are use to boost the belt tension beyond the counterweight force for dynamic sag control.

Maybe you can refine the question to get a better insight. I am sure the above is not exhaustive.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Take-Up Length

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 11:07

Dear Mr.Shane,

I presume that it is related to VGTU only. We fix the take-up pulley at distance of 3m + 2/3 of take up travel ( 3% of belt length as take up travel)from belt top of carrying side.This will take care of all.

Regards.

A.Banerjee

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 11:12

I am more refering to conveyors with take up trolleys that are tensioned using VVVF and Eddy current winches

Shane

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 05:42

It seems you are asking about a powereed takeup. I didnt realize that engineers have wandered into using VVfD's. What happened to hydraulics?

The travel definition requires you provide the dead band details and means of control. We select the normal full load running plus about 10 % as a start point. However, this also depends if you wish the takup force to hold for a 24 hour cycle or less. The temperature extremes must be considered, if using a steel cord belt, or even fabric if you know its expansion properties with teimperature.

I think you need to give more detail to allow a concise recital that addresses your query.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 05:50

Another note.

Eddy current winches are a bad idea. I am aware of their application in the coal operation in OZ. RSA have also applied them. They are an accident waiting to happen as has happened in the VIctoria coal fields.

Eddy current drives can lose torqwue control for various reasons. What happens when you can't hold the tension during a necessary tensioning cycle? I understand from discussions with the engineers, a number of years ago, many conveyors were damaged by this event. Most conveyors do not benefit from powered takeups. It is a myth that the belt rating or safety is improved by their application. Quite the opposite! If you want to know more we can talk.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 10:58

Larry,

Please elaborate on the incidents with Eddy current winches in the Victoria Coal fields, I am most interested

Shane

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 11:03

Larry,

Can you please also explain the reasions why Eddy current winches loose torque control

Shane

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 3. Feb. 2005 - 11:56

An eddy current clutch requires DC flux to transmit torque. What happens when you lose flux? So the designers hooked up a battery backup and its controller and fault sensors. Suds Law still prevails.

The clutch is used to provide variable speed and torque fitted with some controller and logic such as load cell and idea of constant pull (couterweight) regardless of belt response or some derivative of this. They are relatively cheap. Consume lots of power and heat. They have low efficiency at lower speed.....

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 4. Feb. 2005 - 12:01

Their pilot bearing is the weak link. They have an inner and outer rotor. The inner rotor is supported by the outer with a center pilot bearing that cannot be inspected except by removal and examination. SOmetimes the pilot bearing fails and wa la many new parts. Its kind of like the fluid traction coupling and its central bearing failure introducing impeller to runner vanes.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 4. Feb. 2005 - 07:08

Dear Mr Banerjee..

I take issue with your 3% of belt length for take up travel. Assuming you mean 3% of pulley centres, then for a 12kM long overland the take up length would be 360m!!

We have such a conveyor here that is 11.8km long, has a horizontal curve and has a take up travel of 25m and has been operating for many many years.

My old Goodyear blue book gives 1.5% +.65m for fabric and .25% + 1 splice for steelcord.

Regards

LSL Tekpro

Graham Spriggs

Take-Up Length

Posted on 4. Feb. 2005 - 09:42

Dear Mr. LSL Tekpro/Graham,

I am sorry that I did not mention the type of fabric. It is true for NN belting.Belt manufacturer nomally offer you 1% permanent elongation + 1.5 % Elastic. But in actual feild it is 3% in totality.In catalouge you will find 1.5 % only.But no-body is taking into consideration of the same.

So for 12Km, I will not suggest you to go in for NN belting. You have to go in for steel cord belting & travel will be of 0.25%to 0.5%.

Regards.

A.Banerjee

Nepean
(not verified)

Re: Take-Up Lengths

Posted on 8. Feb. 2005 - 02:15

I regret having to read some of the responses to your question pertaining to the Eddy Current winch technology from Larry Nordell. The following points mentioned needs to be set right:

Yes, engineers that require a take up system which operates on the constant tension principle will and do use Eddy Current Winches. Hydraulic winches are expensive and not generally preferred, but achieve the same result i.e. furnish the conveyor with a constant tension.

I object strongly to Larry’s comment that Eddy Current Winches are a bad idea. It is obvious that his knowledge of Eddy Current Winches and their track record as to reliability is totally unknown to him. It would be interesting to see his response as to what happened in the Victoria coal fields.

We have manufactured and supplied Eddy Winches in South Africa for the past 14 years and to date have never had a winch that loses torque. The logic built into the control guarantees a “safe” operation. There is no “tensioning cycle” as the winch operates as a constant tension system and is live throughout the duration of the conveyor operation.

Larry further appears to state that the belt rating or safety is decreased as a result of applying a constant tension, what a poor comment.

There is no and has never been any battery back up on Eddy Current Winches in South Africa.

The Eddy winch does not require a loadcell in order to operate as a tensioning device. The loadcell is purely fitted for indication of the T2 tension in the system.

The Eddy coupling does not have a pilot bearing at all, possibly Larry is thinking of some other non related machine. The Rotor is attached to the output shaft of the motor and rotates freely on the motor bearings and the inductor rotates freely on it’s own set of bearings housed by the inductor carrier.

As for reliability, a Colliery in the Witbank coalfield, installed the first Eddy Current winch in South Africa on a 6km overland conveyor in 1991. This conveyor operates continuously for 6 day a week with conveyor maintenance being done on a Sunday. To date this winch has not failed in any way. One Colliery here has 40 Eddy Current Winches installed since 1992, with no catastrophic failures.

To come back to your original question, the take up length depends on the length of the conveyor, the Drive Start Factor and the modulus of elasticity of the belting being used. Other factors such as the permanent stretch needs to be considered.

I would be more than willing to advise and assist you accordingly should you require assistance.

Alan Exton – Managing Director – Nepean Conveyors (Pty) Ltd.

nepean@iafrica.com

www.nepeanconveyors.com

Tel:+27 11 708 2854

Fax:+27 11 708 2856