Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted in: , on 29. Feb. 2008 - 10:10

To All:

Has anyone seen a steel cord belt curl into a pipe conveyor shape, which was not the designer's intention?

There is no fabric or steel cross-reinforcement. The ST is smaller than normal and has light but normal cover gauge. The width is on the smaller side for steel cord belt, but not abnormal.

Now the belt has 3 points of contact on the idlers. Maybe its patent time.

I personally have not seen such behavior in steel cord construction. If others have such experience, maybe the information can be evaluated as a collective. The belt manufacturer says its no problem. Right!

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 29. Feb. 2008 - 12:55

Larry..

I have not seen a steelcord belt roll into anywhere near as much as a pipe configuration, as I have for fabric ones.

We had some Korean belts which were delivered incorrectly with Nylon warp (longitudinal) as well as Nylon weft (transverse), and these rolled into almost closed pipes especially in the concaves.

The effect was noticed after a couple of days of varying load.

It looked like the varying load worked on pushing the belts into the troughs, and effectively rolled them into a pipes.

(Incidentally, these belts never stoped stretching, and the supplier had to replace them. I believe that the additional stretch in the bottom of the trough in the concave sections has a direct bearing on the pipe shape formation, as the unstretched edges want to take the shortest route instead of the middle bit)

I have not had anything like this effect on the less stretchy EP warp and Nylon weft.

It therefore follows that the higher the modulus of the warp, the less of a pipe you get. Therefore with St of 10 times the modulus, you get 10 times less pipe shape I suppose.

Have a good weekend

LSL Tekpro

Graham Spriggs

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 29. Feb. 2008 - 04:31

Graham,

Thanks for the input.

I have seen a fabric construction where the plys have a diagonal weave, such that when stretched under tension, the belt curls as the diagonal weave wants to collapse and the belt becomes narrower with great elongation I believe an invention was issued for this construction.

The noted steel cord construction curled over time. It even curled while on the shipping reels and it curled as unused samples placed on a desk, neither have seen any product.

It causes special problems in service.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 2. Mar. 2008 - 01:28

Hi Larry,

a) Are the tensions in the cords equal?

b) Are the top and bottom cover compounds the same?

c) If you fillet off the top and bottom cover individually does the cupping go away?

d) Are the coords alternating S and Z?

Regards,

Andrew Hustrulid

Sandvik Mining & Construction

Andrew Hustrulid, Ph.D., PE [EMAIL="andrew@hustrulid.com"]andrew@hustrulid.com[/EMAIL]

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 2. Mar. 2008 - 06:24

Hello Andrew,

The cord tensions are more or less equal and have s & z lays.

The compounds are different as are most modern overland designs with wear compound on top such as DIN X and low rolling resistance on the bottom.

HAve not filleted the covers off yet, nor have the cover properties been tested to date. All will happen in good time.

I feel confident the answer will be determined. I am curious if this behavior has a long life.

Back in Chile?

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 3. Mar. 2008 - 01:11

G'day Larry,

If the amount the rubber compound shrinks or grows while the rubber cures and crosslinking increases is significantly different between the top and bottom cover then I would expect to see some level of cupping. However with "light but normal cover gauge" this should be negligable.

Regarding the long life - I've never seen belt cupping improve significantly until the top cover is worn away!

I'm still seeing the sights here in Australia. Hope to get back to Chile before the kids forget their Spanish.

Regards,

Andrew Hustrulid

Sandvik Mining & Construction

Andrew Hustrulid, Ph.D., PE [EMAIL="andrew@hustrulid.com"]andrew@hustrulid.com[/EMAIL]

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 3. Mar. 2008 - 01:52

Andrew,

We suspect the cupping is due to some differential chemical action between top and bottom covers. One interesting point is the time it took to make the difference. The response is still going on now, about two years from installation. The initial cupping was small. It has grown over time, both on the installed belt and on the remaining reels of unused belt.

Would you purchase from this mfgr.?

I wonder if the mfgr. has done this before, maybe, not to this degree. Thus, the request for anyone that may have a similar experience with steel cord belts.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 20. Mar. 2008 - 12:36

Dear Lawrence,

I have seen quite a few steelcord belts curling.

Two main sources for the problem:

- presence of discontinued weft layers

- manufacturing process.

What is thecover thickness? and what is the rating?

Kind Regards

John Paul

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 20. Mar. 2008 - 05:07

Dear John,

There is no weft. There is no fabric in the belt.

The cover gauges are: 6 mm top and 4 mm bottom.

Strength is St-1200 N/mm range.

Where have you seen steel cords curled before?

A big manufacturer that you know well.

Lawrence Nordell Conveyor Dynamics, Inc. website, email & phone contacts: www.conveyor-dynamics.com nordell@conveyor-dynamics.com phone: USA 360-671-2200 fax: USA 360-671-8450

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 20. Mar. 2008 - 08:00

Dear Lawrence:

prevous curled Steelcord belt:

- TXI Texas

- Copetro Argentina

- SPCC Peru

- Norilsk Russia

- Paksteel Pakistan

Not all to the same grade.

Kind Regards

JP

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 15. May. 2008 - 12:47

Hi

Can someone explain what is meant by S & Z lay of the cords?

Shane

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 16. May. 2008 - 01:11

Originally posted by Shane

Hi

Can someone explain what is meant by S & Z lay of the cords?

Shane

S and Z cords is a code use internationally by steel cord manufacturers to specify the direction of the twist of the filaments within the cable.

In a steel cord belt, each second cord has to be twisted to the right (and same to the left) in order to keep the belt straight.

So one cord is "S", the next one is "Z" and so on.

This is one of the way to ensure a balance between the remaining tensions in the cords after cure.

When you order steel cord for your belt production, the supplier automatically provide 50% S and 50% Z, unless you specify otherwise.

Best Regards

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 19. May. 2008 - 10:49

Hi Larry,

For what it is worth I have seen this happen before but not to the extent you describe. The cause was the compounding or lack thereof and the problem got worse as the top cover was exposed to heat/sun. Essentially what we found was that the rubber lost a great deal of its elasticity and basically shrank. Test the top cover now for physicals against what the original spec for the compound and particularly if the elastic elongation and tensile has dropped off then you can focus on the compounding.

Regards

Col Benjamin

Gulf Conveyor Systems Pty Ltd

Re: Steel Cord Belt Curling Problem

Posted on 29. May. 2008 - 11:10

Originally posted by Colin Benjamin



For what it is worth I have seen this happen before but not to the extent you describe. The cause was the compounding or lack thereof and the problem got worse as the top cover was exposed to heat/sun. Essentially what we found was that the rubber lost a great deal of its elasticity and basically shrank. Test the top cover now for physicals against what the original spec for the compound and particularly if the elastic elongation and tensile has dropped off then you can focus on the compounding.

Regards

Col Benjamin

Gulf Conveyor Systems Pty Ltd

Colin,

you are right.

If there is no weft reinforcements, the curling problem probably comes from the compound. What you describe is a compound where the Pentaeritrithyl Diphosphate is missing. Some manufacturers save money on this expensive but essential additive.

If your hypothesis is right, then cracks on the cover exposed to the sun or the air (ozone) should appear. If not, then the construction of the belt, is the source of the problem.

Best Regards