Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 21. May. 2009 - 11:41

There aren't any. With the development of variable speed electric motor controls the hydraulic motor has slipped into oblivion.

Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 21. May. 2009 - 04:22

Efficiency is the biggest factor to look at - a hydraulic drive is very poor efficiency compared to a VFD electrical / mechanical drive.

Gary Blenkhorn
President - Bulk Handlng Technology Inc.
Email: garyblenkhorn@gmail.com
Linkedin Profile: http://www.linkedin.com/in/gary-blenkhorn-6286954b

Offering Conveyor Design Services, Conveyor Transfer Design Services and SolidWorks Design Services for equipment layouts.

Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 21. May. 2009 - 04:59

Maybe mechanical engineers can understand the operation of hydraulic drives while variable speed electric motor controls are "black magic boxes".

Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 21. May. 2009 - 06:57

The problem with the “black magic boxes” is the ‘wall of not understanding” between mechanical and electrical engineers.

Once the knowledge is combined in one person, the benefits of modern technology pays off.

I always enjoyed this position in my work.

Teus

Teus

Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 22. May. 2009 - 08:18

Thankyou for the reply Sir,

I would further like to know that w.r.t.

1. Maintainence

2. Spares

3. Effective cost of running

Of the two (Hydraulic & VFD), which kind of drive shall be preferred for normal troughed conveyor.

Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 22. May. 2009 - 08:34

Hi all..

The advantage of a variable speed hydraulic drive is that the slower you go, the higher the torque you get for the same power.

This is especially significant for belt feeders where the breakaway torque is often way over twice the running torque.

VSD electrical drives push out little over 160% on start up.

As for conveyors...no advantages over electro-mechanical drives, for most normal installations.

Cheers

LSL Tekpro

Graham Spriggs

Re: Hydraulic Vs. Electro-Mechanical Drive

Posted on 22. May. 2009 - 08:48

1)Oil top ups - filter changes

2)top up oil - filter elements

3)already mentioned

You only resort to hydraulics when you're getting into deep clag.